Nightwing said:

Can I say.....neither?

Xenos said:

I did say they where lame but still shouldn't be in the movies, altleast not Spider-Man's. These movies are suposed to be more realistic and also have a more scientific aproch. How is a damn alien parasite that take it's host by becoming a living costume realistic or scientific? Heck even putting Sandman in the film is a streach.

Scarlet_Spider said:

Xenos said:

I did say they where lame but still shouldn't be in the movies, altleast not Spider-Man's. These movies are suposed to be more realistic and also have a more scientific aproch. How is a damn alien parasite that take it's host by becoming a living costume realistic or scientific? Heck even putting Sandman in the film is a streach.

I think venom's origin is a LOT more realistic than sandmans. At least with venom, it cannot be proven absolute ridiculous as we do not know if aliens exist. whereas with sand... well we pretty much know for fact that a living human being cannot be made of sand.

And spiderman's other enemies aren't realistic either. Lizard is slightly more acceptable.

Xenos said:

Scarlet_Spider said:

Xenos said:

I did say they where lame but still shouldn't be in the movies, altleast not Spider-Man's. These movies are suposed to be more realistic and also have a more scientific aproch. How is a damn alien parasite that take it's host by becoming a living costume realistic or scientific? Heck even putting Sandman in the film is a streach.

I think venom's origin is a LOT more realistic than sandmans. At least with venom, it cannot be proven absolute ridiculous as we do not know if aliens exist. whereas with sand... well we pretty much know for fact that a living human being cannot be made of sand.

And spiderman's other enemies aren't realistic either. Lizard is slightly more acceptable.

But Sand-Man origin in the movie still went with the theme that as been reacuring in the Spidey movies. The science aproch. He stubled onto the testing ground for Quest idustries (The rival company of Ozcorp in the first movie) Where they where doing an experiment to create demolecuularization with sand. Supposedly the sand paticels got mixed into his DNA. While no this is not realitic it fits in better with the movies plot than an alein does.

matacron said:

The symbiote IS still alive. Doesn't anyone here remember that Peter gave a piece of the costume to Dr. Connors to analyze?

matacron said:

The symbiote IS still alive. Doesn't anyone here remember that Peter gave a piece of the costume to Dr. Connors to analyze?

Nightwing said:

That little piece of symbiote at Connors's lab wouldn't be enough to do a new Venom or Carnage. It really too small, that I doubt it would be enough to created a suit. After all, the symbiote that took over both Spidey & Brock was big enough to cover their body while the small one in Connors's lab isn't enough to cover the whole body. Thus, Venom & Carnage in any future sequel is very unlikely. At least I hope no more symbiotes.

Nightwing said:

That little piece of symbiote at Connors's lab wouldn't be enough to do a new Venom or Carnage. It really too small, that I doubt it would be enough to created a suit. After all, the symbiote that took over both Spidey & Brock was big enough to cover their body while the small one in Connors's lab isn't enough to cover the whole body. Thus, Venom & Carnage in any future sequel is very unlikely. At least I hope no more symbiotes.

Xenos said:

I did say they where lame but still shouldn't be in the movies, altleast not Spider-Man's. These movies are suposed to be more realistic and also have a more scientific aproch. How is a damn alien parasite that take it's host by becoming a living costume realistic or scientific? Heck even putting Sandman in the film is a streach.

Darth Tritium said:

Neither.....lets just forget SM3 ever happened and start fresh after Spider-man 2

IcEXMaNuSa said:


ok so a guy getting bitten by a genetic enhanced spider is realistic ? ? ? That is scientifically impossible as well so you can throw out the science part of it. I really love it when people try to use the word realistic in a science fiction area, I mean people do know what that means right ?